Not everyone who talks to a police officer is a criminal.
Not everyone who talks to a police officer is a criminal.
It only applies to those who give testimony against you in court.
If an informant's tip leads to enough hard evidence to convict, they may not need to testify and thus are not your accuser; your accuser is whoever's testifying about that evidence (forensic tech, detective, etc.) Anonymous tips are a thing, after all.
In the UK, even if a witness is giving direct testimony in a trial there are situations which, for safety reasons, the witness might be allowed to be anonymous: https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/witness-protection-and... outlines this.
Imagine there's a stabbing. The police show up and immediately start questioning bystanders. No-one wants to talk. A detective hands out business cards, and says 'if you remember anything, then give me a call on my mobile'.
On the way home, one of the bystanders sees a bloody cloth next to a public bin a block or two away that looks like the knife might be wrapped up in it. They're scared that it might have been a gangland killing, so they call up and report what they saw in confidence, fearing retribution.
The caller's not made any accusation. The physical evidence stands for itself in court. There's no need for an illegal or warrantless search to find the knife, and neither does the tip-off form a basis for creating probable cause for a search.
In this case, at the very least I think it is reasonable for the caller to expect a level of privacy, and the police should be obliged to inform the caller that the call is being recorded.
Also, the app they're talking about isn't a thing that records phone calls on your mobile, it's for accessing the call recorder system.
> Also, the app they're talking about isn't a thing that records phone calls on your mobile, it's for accessing the call recorder system.
That does not seem to be what the article is saying.
> Several police forces in Britain [used] a calling app that recorded hundreds of thousands of phone conversations and illegally retained that data.
> Some 1,015 staff downloaded the software on their work phones and made more than 200,000 records of phone chats, which the regulator reckons was likely with "victims, witnesses, and perpetrators of suspected crimes" and were "automatically saved."
> When enabled, the app records and stores all phone calls made in the mobile device.