This may sound like a conspiracy but I think the industry wants people to buy new content not enjoy the hits from yesteryear.
So they're raking in cash from rent seeking really. It would be healthier for music if what you said was true though.
I actually have quite a large, somewhat curated digital music library and, with a few hundred dollars and a few days of effort, I could probably patch any particular holes I have among songs/albums I especially enjoy, but mostly I use streaming including a lot of curated playlists.