Edit: here’s a graph. I see no reason to feel optimistic. https://ourworldindata.org/greenhouse-gas-emissions
Edit: here’s a graph. I see no reason to feel optimistic. https://ourworldindata.org/greenhouse-gas-emissions
10 years ago, we thought we'd be in a worse situation than we are now. Things are still getting worse, but getting worse at a slower rate. If the change in rate continues, things will start to get better at some point.
If it’s flat 5 years from now then I’d be inclined to agree with you.
Edit: and here is more damning evidence. Greenhouse gases in the atmosphere over time is not flattening.
Second, what matters most is the amount of greenhouse gasses in the atmosphere. Here is a graph of that, and it's continuing to increase. https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/...
One reason that the amount of greenhouse gasses in the atmosphere matters more than emissions is that we could also be reducing the planet's ability to remove greenhouse gasses through things like deforestation. I wish there were evidence to believe we are on the right track, but there isn't any at this stage. There are positive things, but in aggregate, it's getting worse as of this moment, not better.
My evidence is clear, and here. You haven't shown any to support your claims. At this point I can't tell if you are arguing in bad faith, are arguing just to argue, or don't understand the topic. If you don't provide any evidence or sound good faith reasoning after this, I won't reply.
edit: typos
I never claimed GHG wasn't continuing to increase, though maybe that's what you thought I meant. I meant to discuss the original commenter's opinion that global warming was accelerating. It's not accelerating. It's slowing. Emissions are still increasing, yes, because we don't have a deficit. But increasing isn't the same thing as accelerating.
You can also see this in how the actual temperature of the earth (the only metric that matters) has not increased in the past few years. https://climate.nasa.gov/ (click on "global temperature")
Another important metric is that per-capita GHG emissions are declining across the developed world. This indicates we are increasing the efficiency of our society significantly. This is trade-adjusted, so it accounts for emissions embedded in imported goods. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/consumption-co2-per-capit...
"I meant to discuss the original commenter's opinion that global warming was accelerating. It's not accelerating. It's slowing."
I don't think you can conclude this at this time, but even if you want to believe it, it's still increasing (GHGs in the atmosphere and temperatures), and that's very bad news.
"You can also see this in how the actual temperature of the earth (the only metric that matters) has not increased in the past few years"
Again, you can't draw conclusions from 3 data points. Not sure if you are arguing in bad faith here, or simply don't understand. Look back at either the temperature graph or the emissions graph and you can find several 3 year periods where it didn't increase, then it shot right back up again. In the case of the last few years of temperatures, that's due to the La Nina (link below) which lowers temperatures, when we switch back to the El Nino it's going to shoot up again, and likely start breaking records again. We are not on the right track, and all of the evidence shows this.
Emissions not accelerating is of course important because 1) it was what the conversation was literally about and 2) it’s a necessary prerequisite for them going down. Plus, as I showed, emissions are going down, not just not accelerating, in developed nations.
Emissions going down is the right track, emissions going up or accelerating is the wrong track.
What is it you want to see? Zero emissions? Obviously that’s going to take a while, it won’t happen overnight. And before it does, they have to start going down. And zero emissions isn’t even enough, we have to go negative by capturing carbon. Unless we think 1.1C over pre industrial is acceptable. Which obviously we don’t because people are talking about current effects of warming.
So no, not all of the evidence shows that we are not “on the right track”. It’s true only if you ignore the evidence that contradicts your worldview.
Emissions are NOT going down, full stop. At this point it's clear you are arguing in bad faith, so I'm done. 20 years ago people made the exact same dishonest arguments you are now, that over a few data points temperatures stopped going up, climate change was over! Every time there's a La Nina the same bad faith argument returns. In 5 years when it's clear that what you've said is wrong, you'll move on to some other bad faith argument like they did. I've seen the pattern over and over again over the last 25 years.
The evidence I've provided is clear, and I'm confident that anyone with more than two brain cells that reads it will see the obvious reality that it illustrates.
It seems like its easier for you to pretend I'm some kind of global warming denier than to actually engage with what I'm saying.
It's fascinating psychologically, but obviously we're not having a productive conversation. I hope you're able in the future to look at this stuff with clearer eyes. It doesn't seem like you'll be very helpful in solving this problem if this is how you approach it.