It's not an abhorrent response, it's what should be an acceptable response to having to deal with bullshit legal threats from ignorant people. If the copyright owner doesn't want their images linked to, they should take them down from the web or perform such gymnastics such as restricting their serving to their own web server that refuses to serve the images unless certain conditions are met (an HTTP referrer match, a username/password is required, etc.)
Actually, thats not clear cut. Copyright isn't a binary thing, its a license with a bunch of terms that could be anything. Just because its on the internet, it doesn't mean you can do what you want with it. the chances of you getting caught and told off are very slim, but it doesn't mean its right or indeed legal.
> it's what should be an acceptable response to having to deal with bullshit legal threats from ignorant people.
again, its not bullshit. The person created those pictures, and has the right to distribute them as they see fit. Now, if you want to allow people to use your pictures in anyway, then you can. There is nothing stopping you.
However its down to the individual to choose.
It is almost perfectly clear cut. LAION is linking to the images, not redistributing them or storing them. A link. In a text file. To photos. Served from a web server. Presumably, the artist's web server or portfolio site hosted by a company they do business with.
>The person created those pictures, and has the right to distribute them as they see fit.
Yeah, they do have the right to distribute them as they see fit. So, if they don't want them linked to, they can put them behind a paywall.
It's a bullshit legal threat. The artist has a complete knuckle dragging understanding of copyright and the web.
Again its not clear cut. the license could be something like: "you are able to view these images as part of this website, anything else is prohibited" or "direct linking to these images is not allowed, these images are licensed only fir use as part of this website" or something along those lines.
Now, enforcing that is pretty hard. I'm also willing to bet that he didn't make any such license. But to say its a clear cut legal slam dunk isn't correct.
That does not prevent me from including a URI to the comment in a list, along with metadata like "comments that misunderstand copyright law".
The photographer posted photos on a website with the express intent of distributing them there. Neither he, nor you, nor I can retroactively decide we don't like the way someone linked to our publicly-posted content.
He literally sued someone for including a URI in list. That deserves the smack own he got.
It's very... odd. I can't imagine that anyone serious would argue a set of URIs for legally-published content could be legal until hit hits some critical mass (or, worse, until the wrong person downloads it) and then it becomes illegal.
It's nonsensical. If you don't want your content indexed and listed, don't publish it. If you want it seen by people by mostly ignored by well-behaved crawlers, use noindex. It is insane to just publish world-readable stuff, expect to profit from Google/etc indexing it, but being claiming harm and liability for its inclusion in a list.
Since people can take the map, find your address on it, and take pictures of the priceless mural, which they can then use to train a monkey to incorporate the style of the mural into other murals that the monkey creates, thus violating your copyright. And the murals that the monkey produces are not copyrightable.
But also, yes, in that instance, if it's public and the door's open. Your analogy isn't a good one though. I like mine better, to illustrate the hoops the artist had to jump through.
Of course there are restrictions like if your office is already in a private building, probably not. But if it’s facing a public street and I just walk in, how would I know you didn’t leave it open all the time?
If you had some “no tresspassing” “private property” signs up and the door was open, then your scenario is less likely to work.
Or if your documents are locked up in a file cabinet, then I can’t break into it.
Not sure if it is ethical or not, but it technically makes sense, this is all I'm saying.