Do I really want to give Apple more information about myself? Can I trust any company with private information? I think it is kind of creepy that they would know about every album I own (and pay $25/yr for the privelege). What am I missing?
For me, I don't see actionable information from this. What is Apple going to do? Turn me over to the RIAA? Obviously not. At the very worst as far as I can guess, they could great a recommendation engine and try to upsell me more music that I might like. Sort of how a radio station works (inefficiently) or how a home town record store owner used to work ("Hey man did you check out Dylan's latest?") If they shove recommendations at me through email, ping or a "suggestions" feature in iTunes, I can ignore it. And it causes me less hassle than junk postal mail.
Seriously, what can they do with it?