We’d be in better shape if we’d kept the rules we wrote after 2008 to keep 2008 from happening again.
The problems in 2023 were made significantly worse by the rollback on liquidity rules in 2017, which, if we may recall, was not a year that Obama was exerting any influence on banking rules.
The Fed has stress tested for duration since Dodd-Frank. The unsophistication of SVB’s duration simulations was specifically flagged by supervisors ex ante.
Subjecting SVB, Signature and First Republic to LCR requirements would have thrown up early red flags. (You’re partly correct in that the definition of liquid assets is too broad: Treasuries of all kinds get equal weight.)
> media is misleading people about this because they really, really want it to be a story about right wing anti-regulation politicians
The 2017 rollback was bipartisan.
There was also substantial, systematic mortgage fraud by lenders.
I’m sure if banks had donated and lobbied less, some would be in jail.
Again, what was the fraud by lenders? You seem to have to taken the view that securitization turns fraud by borrowers into fraud by lenders.
They were rated as prime but were actually junk.
There was no criminal investigation because the US DoJ decided not to. Civil suits didn’t get far because it was hard to gather information without criminal jurisdiction.
Obama got almost $50M from Wall Street for his 2008 election and it paid off well for his donors. [1]
With that much fraud, there should have been more criminal convictions rather than bonuses as usual.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_rating_agencies_and_the... [1] https://www.opensecrets.org/industries/recips.php?ind=F&cycl...
Now you may argue that banks accepted fraudulent applications that a prudent man would not have and then sold securities based on those, and all the big banks paid out multibillion dollar settlements over that.
Why no criminal prosecution? Two reasons. IANAL, but I believe the standard for criminal fraud is higher than imprudent decisions. Second, and more importantly if you start charging bank employees criminally, you really need to start charging the fraudulent borrowers who by many accounts number in tens of thousands. No one made them commit fraud. They were not victims of fraud, they were literally beneficiaries, though ultimately foolish as well.
https://theintercept.com/2016/07/12/eric-holders-longtime-ex...
https://freebeacon.com/issues/eric-holder-misled-congress-de...