The RFC seems to presuppose that there has been an initial trust setup (since it says the the client has a pass-phrase already). How do you setup that that initial pass-phrase without TOFU?
Certificates are a scam.
My solution which is convoluted and relatively insecure if you have a persistent MITM is to require a password change that you can encrypt with the old password, then the MITM has to remember the old password to know the secret.
But you are right that OTP only are safe after the secret has been shared. Just like all crypto including HTTPS and SSH.
HTTPS is _not_ more secure in any way. The lock icon is an illusion.
As for the technical reasons:
- Big-ints are not trivial in js.
- DNS is centralized.