At their core, passkeys are a easy and nice way to move from passwords to public private key cryptography. And hardware based authentication does allow more security. And by leveraging the tpm, hardware-backed keystore, or security enclave, you can use your phone and computer the way FIDO keys are already used.
But there are many reasons why I will wait as long as possible, maybe indefinitely before I start using passkeys. The idea of this being tied to Google or any other major company for my logins is not okay. There are many cases of people being locked out of Google accounts without the ability to appeal. I don't appreciate the idea of large companies being able to whitelist which passkeys are allowed, which is possible depending on how attestation certificates are handled. With current 2factor, you can control the secrets yourself if you choose to. While it's true that you can't be phished into sharing your passkey as easily, you also lose a lot of convience and flexibility in login management. And it makes login sharing or multi-account management very inconvenient and difficult.
I was hopeful with 2FA rolled out that my accounts would be more secure, but most companies give you very little control over which methods of 2FA are allowed or enabled. I don't want to be forced to enroll a phone number just to enable TOTP 2FA. I want to be able to choose between TOTP or HOTP for my accounts. I don't want to be forced to use a 2FA app that doesn't allow me to export and manage the secrets myself. In some ways FIDO keys solve some of those issues, but the hardware security aspect of it contradicts giving the end user the choice to self manage. I expect some policies will change over time based on uptake and issues people face.
https://www.concordlawschool.edu/blog/constitutional-law/fif...
Edit: Apparently, in iOS and Android, passkeys are backed up to the cloud, and iOS even allows you to airdrop them.
https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/blog/what-are-passkeys-an...