Regarding the comparisons you propose. I don't see how [1] is equivalent. The mechanics are quite different. In Alchemix you receive a lump-sum at the beginning and pay it back gradually through the protocol that is using your collateral to obtain yield in various yield-bearing assets.
[2] is closer in spirit. But as far as I know you can get liquidated. You have a repayment schedule and if you don't meet your obligations then your collateral will be impacted. In Alchemix your collateral is locked bringing some yield, there is no fixed repayment schedule, it adapts based on the yield.
Anyway, the point was not to promote any of these smart contract and I have no affiliation with any of them. It was simply to illustrate the OP that it's not vapor ware, it exists, is implemented and is working today. It's niche, it's not for everyone, but is not vapor ware.