I took it as being about this website or something the website represents. I do hope no one is against reading in general.
> I took it to mean that the best way to learn (…) start by googling a specific aspect
People learn different subjects in different ways. Perhaps googling fits some people and some subjects, but if you don’t know anything about a field you don’t know which questions it makes sense to search for or which websites to trust.
> but I think there's also a false promise of knowledge offered by sites like this.
I don’t get that at all from this particular website. They’re quite open that they’re presenting “the best books as recommended by X”. The person doing the recommendation is an integral part, they are interviews.