One has to ask: was that to the benefit of society?
Google may make good use of this tech. But it would be better for all of us if everyone did and didn't have to pay them a fee for the privilege.
This is reverse logic because then Google would not have published the tech and would have kept it a trade secret.
In this case, google might not have funded the development of transformers which could dramatically reduce costs of everything for humanity.
Same goes for drug development.
That said, I think there’s a question around software patents and how long they should last. Perhaps it should just be to recoup costs, plus some multiple. I’m not sure.
That doesn't seem likely to me. And if it were true that Amazon was so vulnerable that checkout flow click parity would wipe them out, I hardly think the law should intercede to save them - that seems like a scenario where they had a bad business model.
I went to a talk done by Amazon's longest serving IP lawyer and he explicitly called out that Amazon has only gone to court (or asserted its patent, can't remember the phrase) over a kindle related patent.