traditional farming depletes the soil, so the whole 'doesn't scale to the whole planet' is only a good argument over an artificially short time horizon.
Traditional farming in the UK has had a run of a few thousand years on land that isn't flood plains ..
Perhaps you're thinking of more modern farming practices?
They have. Traditional farming is very taxing on micronutrients.
China (and Egypt) used a lifehack called "silt". Basically, they use it to periodically replace the topsoil.