Then there's the lack of network support.
If this is pushed on Linux users, expect forking of distributions.
Then there's the lack of network support.
If this is pushed on Linux users, expect forking of distributions.
You can't have it both in this case it seems.
As a user I know one thing: X11 is huge and while it has all the nice features, it's also still a slow and laggy beast. This might be caused by bad drivers, or it might be caused by a bad architecture (or bad drivers caused by bad architecture making it impossibly hard to write good drivers).
As such, I'm curious to see whether a restart based on technology newer than the 80ies might solve the two big issues I'm having with Unix GUI at this point.
If it does, I'm happy.
If it doesn't, I'll be on the lookout for a better solution.
But I know one thing: If a long-year X11 developer (Kristian Høgsberg is working on the xorg x server) tells us that our issues are practically impossible to fix without a rewrite using a different architecture, then I believe them. Why?
Because for them it would likely be much less work to fix the existing thing (especially if it is nearly 30 years old and as such should be very mature and bug-free), so if they prefer a rewrite, there must be some truth to that.
Personally, I don't care about either bloat (unless said bloat leads to other issues than me having to buy a bit more RAM and diskspace) or NIH, but I still to this day haven't found a Linux distribution that has a GUI which works as-well as OSX or Windows (window drawing issues, multi monitor support - heck - just changing resolutions at times), so I'm certainly open to see other paths explored.
(Edit: I use XFCE, not GNOME)
I am not sure who is to blame, X or the drivers. But most users won't care. They'll see that GNU/Linux has a bad desktop experience, and revert to whatever they were using.
So this sample of two users seems to indicate that your problem is with drivers. Wayland will make no difference to your experience of Ubuntu.
This is because Wayland is meant to be a subset of the functionality of X. It's not meant to do new things, it's meant to strip off 3 decades worth of cruft that is of little value today.
Note that Wayland is not ran by a bunch of random people who decided that X sucks and that they can do better -- a vast majority of the commits are by veteran X developers.
I realize many people care a lot about the network part of X11. I suppose especially if you are working as Sysop it might be a big deal. I've not used it for over a decade, so obviously not something I care about so much. But on the programming side that client&server split makes life a lot harder and is not a solved problem.