I generally liked mailing lists back in the day when people took the time to craft very specific questions and responded with succinct answers. The results seemed more easily searchable to find relevant threads, which I would feel good about reading in detail, or skipping entirely.
I dunno... maybe there are just way more people asking questions or participating nowadays (regardless of whether it's in a forum, Discord, or Github), so the volume of information is naturally way up, or maybe it's our cultural shift to "more of everything in less time" (so people aren't averse to searching first and posting after not finding vs. asking something previously answered), but the end result for me is a feeling of trying to find the interesting conversations in a party held in a packed stadium vs. a party held in someone's living room.