This is exactly what Wikipedia should be doing. They cannot know what the truth is, they can only provide a summary of existing sources.
In specific cases it might seem stupid, but I think in general it makes sense. It goes hand in hand with the "no original research" policy.
(Like everything in wikipedia that policy can be misapplied by small minded people, though.)
But let's be careful about wording. It obviously shouldn't happen in an encyclopedia. But it obviously should be happening. And it did. He went on to write an authoritative secondary source and the article is sure to reflect it.