You've repeated a few times that the top performers left because of WFH, but I don't believe you. Unless you're in some weird industry where top performers love vibrant offices (which don't really exist) this seems made up.
I think the discourse on forums like this one and Reddit, dominated by highly-online folks (especially engineers), has given folks a skewed perspective on the general population's preferences regarding office work. Most folks in my personal network do not work in tech. Among them the solid majority prefer a hybrid setup, with only a small portion preferring full-time remote or full-time in-office. But that leads to a very strong majority preferring that their organization have an active and vibrant office.