This still externalizes the costs for expensive cars onto the the general population, as the rates for the mandatory insurance will then increase to cover the ever increasing costs of such minor accidents.
Cars were a failure and I believe we'd all be better off if they'd never been invented or at least hadn't been met with the enthusiasm of petrol-financed politicians that turned our cities, infrastructure, housing policies and everyday life into something that largely depends on cars.
Looking at cities like Paris, Barcelona or Amsterdam that broke the dominance of cars makes it clear, that the quality of our lives drastically improves by not leaning into a car-centric design.