Too much stress might be bad, but there's an optimal level of stress and it is definitely not zero.
Software that doesn't get tested will be full of bugs, students that don't get tested will misunderstand the material.
People need reward function. They need clear motivation. If they don't have money / grades / other goals, very few will be internally motivated enough to do things out of sheer will. Just like communism doesn't work because people need to see the carrot in front of their face to be motivated.
By the way, in actually communist countries, their education was even more stressful and competitive. If you decide to not use carrots, you're very likely to find yourself using sticks.