> “AWF [Andy Warhol Foundation] contends that the Prince Series works are ‘transformative,’ and that the first fair use factor thus weighs in AWF’s favor, because the works convey a different meaning or message than the photograph. But the first fair use factor instead focuses on whether an allegedly infringing use has a further purpose or different character, which is a matter of degree, and the degree of difference must be weighed against other considerations, like commercialism."
It seems like there's a strong possibility that if you use any tool, but especially an automated tool, explicitly to generate work "based on Artist Name's work" and then you try to sell it for substantially the same purpose as Artist Name's original work with an explicit goal to avoid the commercial ramifications of licensing those rights from Artist Name, then the courts might not see that as fair use under this new precedent.
This is immensely important, say, if Artist Name is a writer that a studio is trying to replace while maintaining their style by asking an AI to mimic their style, or an actor where the studio wants to use an AI-generated likeness in place of paying them. And of course, this means that studios will try to get these creators to sign their rights away explicitly - which makes some of the current collective action all that much more important!