I think the problem is it is unethical to do the kinds of experiments necessary to come up with any certain facts in the field of nutrition.
At a minimum, you would need to force people to eat a certain diet, with no option to sneak in a few snacks while the researchers aren't watching.
And you probably need to do this for a whole generation (ie. from birth until death) to really get good data to prove that diet X leads to better outcomes than diet Y.