> so I'm really lost about what you're saying here.
Numeric representation may be the same[0], but the rules of how to do math on them, and what that math means, are different.
--
[0] - AFAIK dealing with Bayesian math, it's usually more useful to take a logarithm of all probabilities, so you can add them instead of multiplying. This translation expands the range from <0, 1> to <-infinity, +infinity>, and incidentally makes it clear why some people say that "zero and one are not probabilities".