In it, it shows that for food staple crops, the selling price of the crops only makes up .1% of the cost to produce them, while for vegetables they sell for 9% of the cost to produce. Pretty damming.
Is there a future though where renewables continue to get cheaper and LED tech improves that would address this or will it be forever foolhardy to replace the sun?
Also, even if they are currently not profitable in US, they can easily become profitable in the next 5-10 years if climate changes more, fusion energy becomes cheap etc.
The technology itself vastly outperforms traditional farms.
I’d say the real path to viability is cheaper renewables and food and water becoming far more expensive. The western part of the US uses an unsustainable amount of water for agriculture. That situation is going to implode in the near future. So this scenario might happen.
Fusion energy isn’t even expensive at the moment, it just doesn’t exist.
“Many analysts are confident the high-tech greenhouses can be operated profitably in the U.S. because they have been run successfully in Europe and Canada. Vertical farms are another story. No company has made money operating one on a large scale.”
Greenhouses still use soil and the sun
The two key factors: soil and sun. If you have to replace either, you're increasing your costs. Especially sun: if you use LEDs instead of solar illumination, it's hard to do it cheaply enough in the long run, nor produce calorie crops (as opposed to greens) -- there's simply an energy-in-energy-out balance that's hard to achieve.
Well managed traditional greenhouses can do quite a lot.
Boy you're leaning rilly far out of one of those windows that vertical farms typically do not have