Finland Electricity Prices Flip Negative After Glut of Hydroelectric Power
businessinsider.com
businessinsider.com
> In practice, it doesn't appear any ordinary Finns are being paid to consume electricity. People pay a markup on the electricity, and often pay agreed rates for power instead of the raw market price.
Or am I completely misunderstanding negative priced electricity? Is it just a clickbait term?
Maybe not even melt. The copper might skip the liquid phase and just vaporize to gas at those temperatures.
--------
Power to ground doesn't just mean wasting electricity. It also means perfectly turning that energy into heat.
We are screwed by thermodynamics. Energy is never wasted, just converted to different forms. We usually call heat waste but in utility scale power design (Megawatts+) it's not easy to find energy sinks in practice that can absorb excess energy generated.
-------
In practice, you want the generators to stop making electricity (at least, the generators that __can__ stop in time). But some equipment cant stop in time to respond to the hourly electricity market.
You have traders taking/offloading risk.
I'm not familiar with this micro-market, but power prices go negative in the US frequently where tax incentives make it profitable to operate renewables plants at prices < -$20/MWh.
The day-ahead market prices electricity based on projections. This helps utility companies figure out how much to spin up peaker plants or maybe the local Pumped Hydro station the hours of the day they should release water to generate electricity.
I don't think the day-ahead market ever goes negative.
But the day-of market, maybe just an hour ahead of any particular time, needs finer balance that these big systems can't react to in time. This price of electricity the hour of use is often negative.
It exists because yesterday's projection wasn't perfect and there is too much electricity on the grid right now.
Some systems can react instantly, but if those instant reaction systems are all used up, it's cheaper to pay negative.
--------
Ex: a hydro dam also is juggling the water needs of the community downstream. They cannot send too much, or too little water. They are already set on dropping 100 tons of water today at 10am and cannot change their plans.
So someone else needs to catch all that electricity that will be generated from that event. You can't just 'not drop the water', because people downstream will not get their water.
I doubt you get paid to take electricity in the simple sense and presume it's more similar to pricing situations in the US where it's a price signal (penalty) for congesting the grid but few plants are injecting, unless they're reaping tax incentives.
1. Wholesale spot energy prices don't include transmission charges and other non-energy costs.
2. Don't forget someone might've contracted for that power so regardless of the price, they have to physically or financially settle.
They mention the hydro dams, but I'm assuming they all have spillways for shedding water without generating electricity, which they would use if forced to pay to generate.
Since we already have a grid, it doesn't make monetary sense for every such onflexible producer to invest in their own flexibility unless they can do it for cheaper than the market rate of paying what is effectively a fine every so often.
https://www.svk.se/om-kraftsystemet/kontrollrummet/
The page is in Swedish, but i am guessing the important information is still comprehensible (Vatten = Hydro/Water, Kärnkraft = Nuclear).
As you can see (if you read this today), the electricity is at €0 in both Finland, mid/north Sweden and north Norway.
Finland just finished their long awaited nuclear power reactor OL3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olkiluoto_Nuclear_Power_Plant
Before the new reactor the normal situation for them would be to import some electricity from Sweden/Norway.
What happened today is that Finland's nuclear power is on full steam, while wind power in Sweden is producing a lot (more than nuclear in both Finland and Sweden a the moment, Sweden has a couple of reactors down for maintenance today).
Hydro in Sweden is producing very little today, guessing as little as is practically possible.
Really? https://yle.fi/a/74-20032375 from 10 days ago says "The output of Finland's newest nuclear power facility, Olkiluoto 3, has been significantly cut back because electricity has become too cheap" (Was on HN 2 days ago at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36069517 .)
It goes on to say: "Generally, the amount of electricity generated in Finland is regulated by increasing or decreasing the amount of hydroelectric power that is used. However, due to flood conditions in northern Finland, reducing hydroelectric-generated electricity is challenging at the moment."
Hydro power is rather small in Finland, and it actually seems they increased nuclear power from 3.9GW to 4.3GW during the day today.
(again: https://www.svk.se/om-kraftsystemet/kontrollrummet/ )
This page says that 4.3 GW is very close to the nuclear capacity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_Finland
There seem to be limits on efficient transmission and synchronization of power on the grid.
Connections to import or export excess power are limited in practice. Finding local storage options (pumped hydro, compressed air, etc. Etc.) seems key.
--------
Local grids can use the free market (ex: negative prices electricity) to encourage use or savings from the public. Ex, electric car owners can wait for negative electricity before charging. At least, in theory they could.
It's all a bit handwavey and futuristic. But these things are possible if we solve a few key issues over the next decade.
Energy storage could be partially solved by load shifting: we kindly ask and encourage chargers at certain time, washer/driers or even AC with $$$ incentives to reward those who load shift.
It can also be attacked with utility scale storage. And finally additional export/import power lines to other grids.
But the limitation here is the power grid. The cables to southern Sweden and south Norway can not handle the export.
And the cables to Germany is even more strained. Some say that this is good for us because otherwise our electricity price would have been much higher last winter.
But there's only so much power you can transmit over the interconnects. If I read the list right, in 2019 Finland could generate 17.3 GW but only transfer 3.9 GW out of the country. Going further requires going through even more interconnects, which might have even lower capacity.
There are long-term goals to increase capacity. There's also opposition to those increases.