A carrier leaving the market doesn't bode well. It is hard to enough to get on the property ladder for first time buyers, the challenge may soon become staying on it.
A carrier leaving the market doesn't bode well. It is hard to enough to get on the property ladder for first time buyers, the challenge may soon become staying on it.
(I don’t have a $10K deductible because the savings over $5K wasn’t meaningful in my case.)
So, sure, you can absorb a ten thousand dollar deductible. Can you afford another twenty grand (or more) on top of that for some place to live while your home is repaired/rebuilt?
At the same time, the disaster created a construction labor shortage, and the price of construction increased 20-30% between the insurance payout and permit approvals.
Stricter regulations are required. In particular, it should be illegal to block permits for equal or improved structures, and the insurance companies should be on the hook for the total cost of reconstruction/buying a new home up to the day the homeowner moves in (minus deductible).
What I'm saying is that for anything major you're likely already going to be out of pocket for thousands, perhaps tens of thousands of dollars in costs that your insurance company won't cover in addition to the deductible. Maybe you have ten grand to piss away on a deductible. Do you have twenty? Thirty?
Living in a house with smoke damage while it gets repaired is significantly more harmful to your quality of life (especially if you're WFH) than driving a car with accident damage.
So, yeah, a high deductible seems insane to me.
Focusing on reducing the $10k deductible to e.g. $2k, but leaving the other $20k to remain seems like a backward strategy to me.
For a single-family home I would've been covered but the amount of loss-of-use coverage is generally tied to the rest of the coverage you've got which is tied to the value of your home. With the cost of 'short term' housing (at least in the Bay Area) you're likely to blow through your limits pretty quick even if you ignore all of the other costs related to loss of use (commute, food, utilities, etc.).
Keep in mind the vast majority of homeowners insurance policies aren't "we're going to make you whole", they're "we'll pay for certain, named events up to a dollar amount". The things that your carrier excludes are likely to be things that every other carrier in your state will exclude.
Besides the bet that you'll save money with a $10,000 deductible falls apart once you make a second claim in fifty years. The best numbers I could find suggest that homeowners typically file a claim every 9–10 years. You've likely already blown through the projected savings by the second decade, by year fifty? The lower deductible would've been much cheaper.
Are there cases of minor damage to burning houses? If it burns it burns? The price with deductible would only be lower proportionally to the maximum possible damage.
I had a flood in my house with a 5k deductible and when we told the restoration company we were going private on the services they magically reduced the price by 50% and we only paid 3k out of pocket. You also have to take into account that trades will jack the prices on insurance claims which is going to be baked into your monthly rate, so if you can go private when possible you can also save money in the long run.
Based on this thread, I just went back and re-priced them (my insurance has a nice-enough online quoter for basic transactions like this). The curve had shortened some and so, while I could pay $25K out of pocket, I upped my deductible to $10K and doubled my personal liability coverage. Starting next month, I'll be saving a little over $500/yr and have a more personal liability coverage to boot.
Amusingly, there are coverages that have a $500 deductible. Who the hell wants to even talk to an insurance company over a loss that doesn't significantly exceed a $1K deductible? My insurance discounts include a $495/yr discount for "no claims in the last 5 years". If I had a $500 deductible and had even a $2500 loss, I shouldn't submit it if it would remove that discount for 5 years...