But I would want to know what they've done themselves to evaluate the weight of their expertise. If they have impressive projects, their criticism means something.
there was a koan about the progression of someone's Java program from beginner to intermediate, to expert to master to enlightened. The code for the enlightened looked the same as the beginner.
These koans are useful too
https://prirai.github.io/books/unix-koans.html
Edit: In other words, say a developer that criticized wordpress, do you respect what they say more than the success and value of wordpress (of the wordpress developers)?