Completely agree with this. It took me 7-8 years of professional development before I fully realised that I needed to stop being clever without a really good reason.
A really good reason would be to significantly improve performance or reduce a maintainence burden (e.g. loads of duplication). A good reason would not be "elegance" or an abstraction which might be useful one day.
One of things I loathe about code review is fighting for simplicity against people who haven't figured it out yet.