Communism as it exists today results in authoritarianism/fascism, I think we can agree on that. The desired end state of communism (high resource distribution) is being commingled with the end state of communism: fascism (an obedient society with a clear dominance hierarchy).
You use communism in some parts of your post to mean a high resource distribution society, but you use communism in other parts of your post to mean high oppression societies. You identify communism by the resource distribution, but critcize it not based on the resource distribution but by what it turns into: authortarianism.
What you're doing is like identifying something as a democracy by looking at voting, but criticizing it by it's end state which is oligarchy.
It takes effort to prevent democracy from turning into oligarchy, in the same way it takes effort to prevent communism from turning into authoritarianism.
Words are indirect references to ideas and the ideas you are referencing changes throughout your post. I am not trying to accuse you of bad faith, so much as I am trying to get you to see that you are not being philosophically rigorous in your analysis and therefore you are not convincing because we aren't using the same words to represent the same ideas.
You are using the word communism to import the idea of authortarianism and shut down the analysis without actually addressing the core criticism McFarland was making against capitalist societies.
Capitalism is an ideology of "me," and if I had a replicator, I would use it to replicate gold, not food for all the starving people in Africa. I would use it to replicate enough nuclear bombs to destroy the world, so if someone took it from me, I could end all life on the planet ensuring that only I can use it. So did scarcity end despite having a device that can end scarcity? No. Because we are in a "me" focused stage of humanity rather than an "us" focused stage of humanity so I used it to elevate my own position rather than to benefit all mankind.
Star Trek promotes a future of "us" and that is why it's so attractive. McFarland was saying that "us" has to come before the end of scarcity, and I agree with his critique.