So it makes sense that most regions (or even individual countries) will ultimately end up making their own, locally.
So it makes sense that most regions (or even individual countries) will ultimately end up making their own, locally.
And many of those inputs are mined from only a handful of concentrated places on Earth, and so need to be shipped long distances regardless in order to disperse to where humans actually live and demand the end products.
A better argument for localization might be that the dangerous and explosive nature of battery cells makes shipping the finished product longer distances more risky (and therefore more costly) than shipping the non volatile inputs long distances. So the extra cost of shipping cells drives localization of production.
Pouch and "blade" cells are much less standard, and are also used in a bunch of EVs, like GM's Ultium platform.
Following through the examples in the article, the battery factories are all also including battery cell manufacturing either onsite or nearby. (The BMW example has "an agreement to source next generation lithium-ion battery cells from Envision AESC, which will build a new plant in the state." The others are combo cell+battery factories, like Tesla does.)
That's why they are making the cells near the pack assembly facilities. It's because they are planning to use those specific cells.
So I guess if I scale that up to an EV battery, volume about a third of a cubic metre, so about seven or eight times the volume, that's still less than ten dollars per EV battery shipped across an ocean, if you've got a ship full of them.
I don't know what the total parts and labour cost of an EV battery is, but by this admittedly fast, brutal and half-remembered back of envelope calculation the numbers only have to be a few tens of dollars different to make it worth building them on the other side of the planet and shipping them across an ocean.
No. The shape is cylinder. They're not model specific. https://cleantechnica.com/2020/09/22/everything-you-need-to-...
Of course the dream would be something where you could basically pour "molten battery" into whatever shape you wanted, and then use it - removing all the wasted space.
Just the Y. The standard range pack for the 3 is prismatic LFP. And I think the standard range Y may be haded that way. There was also a recent rumor that the newest 3LR is now LFP, but I don't know if that's been confirmed.
We could not take some other 21700s and make a roughly equivalent pack without a good deal of effort. The thermal characteristics, impedance, length, width, diameter, would be different. There may not even be any cells available with equivalent form factor and performance characteristics.
We haven't seen Tesla or anyone else taking "commodity" 21700 cells and mixing and matching them and throwing them into a pack, it's not possible to do that. Usually, we pick one or two cell manufacturers. It's telling that even Tesla, with their massive buying power, doesn't purchase from LG, Sony or Samsung, only Panasonic in the West for NCA and CATL in China for LFP. Why exactly do we think that is?
It's not quite at the level of people saying computer chips are commodities, and you can just plug your device into one interchangeably. But these cells are not easy and simple. We tend to just think something's easy because we don't have good experience with it. For lithium ion, under the hood, there's enough complexity and risk that the details become very important, very quickly.
Source: I used to work for a major 18650/21700 cell manufacturer. I have torn down many battery packs and cells and know what's inside. And, it's well publicized that only Panasonic cells were in Model 3s for ages. If picking and choosing cells were so easy, and cells are really commodities, then why would Tesla bind themselves to a single cell manufacturer? Answer: They wouldn't. Cells are not generally interchangeable, not by a long shot.
That being said, I would not go so far to say the cells are "custom made". The packs, sure. But cells are close variants of the same technology and process, and many smaller and lower customers may just use the same cells from a single manufacturer.
You are incorrect about batteries not needing high tech and high cost manufacturing plants. In fact, the requirements around cleanliness and process control are very high, for yield, cost and safety reasons. Capital equipment costs and knowledge base requirements are high. I'm not sure how they compare to the requirements around leading edge microchips, but I would imagine that they would want to use similar approaches.
As far as shipping goes, cells are shipped around via air freight all the time. They are going to need to get shipped regardless at some point. And, to the contrary, given my experiences with ground freight in general, I would not want to send cells via ground services.
Pretty clear answer to that one. The battery maker put up 100% of the initial capital to tool up the battery-making facility. Tesla only had to pay for the building.