And then add on RLHF and instruct tuning which is bizzarely more capable than anybody reading the RL/T5 papers that lead to these largely expected at the time.
It's the gap in researcher experiences vs assumptions as of 2017 that lead to this description imo. If you had projected the performance from 2012 to 2017 in NLP, you'd have about 3 major advancements, around word embeddings, and there wasn't much room for innovation there (as it turned out, although obviously semantic search and stuff followed to an extent, it kind of existed as "IR"). But from 2017 to 2023, we've had 30 of similar calibre, and they've stacked (GPT-2, then GPT-3, then instruct/RLHF basically).
The real point, as I see it, is that if we have the same jump - we outperform expectations by an order of magnitude - we'd be in trouble. Now maybe the expectations have adjusted, but I can tell you even as of 1 year ago, many NLP labs still disliked and ignored GPT models in favour of clearly relatively obsolete/now academic-curiosity projects.