> someone needs to pay for it
This is centralized thinking. In a decentralized open protocol system, everyone pays for their own way, but it's very cheap at an individual level. There's no central "it".
> Not web 1.0. Usenet and mailing lists(mostly) died for that, as did many "traditional" forums.
I'm on several email groups where I've been a participant since the very early 90s. Every so often there's the "oh have you seen this new shiny thing, let's move to that!"
Every single one of those new shinies have disappeared, but the email group lives on.
Why? Because email is 100% decentralized, nobody owns it, there's nothing to own. It's an open protocol. So it lives on forever.
Also, I still read Usenet on most days, just like I've been doing since the late 80s. It's alive (if not very active) because nobody owns it.
I wish we could collectively learn these lessons. Centralized systems cannot exist for very long.