A place to share media reviews and recommendations. Wiki-like is OK, as long as table support is great.
Difficulty: it should be able to helpfully look up and create entries for any new media it encounters, using various online sources (IMDB, The Movie Database, TVDB, maybe the Musicbrainz DB, something else authoritative-ish for video games, books, and comic books). So if you want to add a title to a table of, say, sci-fi movies, and link that to a review of same, if it's already got the movie, it should recommend it based on the title you type in, and if not, it should find likely candidates to suggest, and fill in things like release year, director, actors, et c., from outside sources, automatically, when you select one of them. It should be able to find all mentions of a given piece of media within its system, such that one could look up a page for a given, say, album, and get a list of every page where it's mentioned on the site.
It should also maintain a watched/listened/played/read list for each user, and be able to import that from places like Letterboxd.
Basically, a Wiki with smart media metadata import.
It's the only thing we want to do that's not served adequately by chat.