The straw men here is that everything should be sacrificed at the alter of a better economy. Which is not what was claimed.
This idea that we would all be better off if you simply had some of my stuff is bad and wrong.
That was a pretty strange assumption. Nobody wants your house. I just don’t care if you won’t be able to sell it with any profit or even for the same amount of money. However, if property prices go down everywhere, you will be able to exchange it for equivalent property elsewhere.
Full disclosure: I invested in property myself and I’m fine burning that money if the outcome is healthier economy.
I’m all for a healthier economy, don’t get me wrong. It’s just kind of annoying for people to treat my largest asset as some kind of externality. It’s super that you are so generous to burn your money to help everyone but I would prefer to explore solutions that don’t intentionally detonate one of the most important markets in our economy and one that I cannot reduce my exposure to because I am naturally less inclined to give things away.
I'm a bit at a loss here. I was getting all warmed up to try to have an argument with you but it appears you're probably right. Well, you can't win them all.
Look I get it, it’s annoying to live in a dump where so many people live in public for whatever reason (lack of educational opportunities, structural racism, gender violence, poor healthcare, you name it, I agree it’s important) but if thirty percent of my income isn’t helping I sincerely doubt fifteen percent of my house is going to help much either. Sadly, I just don’t have that much to give.
But you have contradicted yourself. My “investment” (a strange thing to call my home but if you are more comfortable using your weird language constructs, so be it) is not being devalued for “arbitrary reasons” under your plan. Instead, it would be systematically torpedoed using the same old combination of the political system plus my money, with the additional kicker of some of the value of my home.
No, sir, what you are considering is not an arbitrary reason why my investment might decline, but a concerted political effort to shift the value of my home away from me.
Proposal: you should remain living in Europe and I will hope that your plan is successful where you live.
If it's not an investment then there is no problem for you. You continue to own your house, nothings changed. No one comes to take the house from you. You can keep living there. You exchanged money for the utility of owning a house. The utility of the house won't change. So I'm not sure why you are so salty about the proposal.
Besides, it wasn't my proposal. I'm not arguing for or against it. I only called out your strawman.
Imagine, if you will, a place where all of a sudden, they did this. Subsequently, some of the people who live there wanted to leave. But they couldn't because they were trapped in their five hundred thousand dollar house. If they sold it, they couldn't pay off the mortgage because now it's worth three hundred thousand dollars.
Would they be salty? Why or why not?
I’m guessing that you probably don’t have a finance background.