Isn't pulumi aws just terraform under the hood still? Why wouldn't I just use terraform's CDKTF instead?
It depends.
The AWS "Classic" provider uses the terraform provider [1].
The AWS "Native" provider does not, and instead uses the AWS Cloud Control API [2].
No everything is available vs TF HCL, it uses CDK from AWS CDK and tries to bridge things to TF have codegen. There’s a lot of weird corner cases and inconveniences. It even uses React under the hood.
Pulumi at least takes care of it better. Maybe not perfectly but better.