There is, of course, a line - i don’t think working at McDonald’s when you are 17 is trauma. But working physical labor when you are 12 is.
Young actors or athletes can work very demanding jobs without suffering directly, it’s everything around that work which is often problematic. I bring this up because it’s suffering that’s problematic be that at an elite prep school or a factory, however 12 year olds often enjoy being productive when it’s within their capabilities.
uh yeah? because children are the most vulnerable in our society and need to be protected from people who are trying to exploit them? do you make this same argument for age of consent laws?
> a baptism by fire that carved character out of raw-boned desperation and grueling sweat
i prefer our current standards of living. i suspect that five-year-olds do too.
> The system is a diabolical puppeteer, offering up a sanitized, sterile version of life
yes, this is what progress looks like. instead of toiling in mines, our children can be children.
> bereft of the hardened steel that labor forges
citation needed.