Low Interest Rates being ineffective against Inflation does not imply High Interest Rates are effective against inflation.
Economics doesn't allow us to conduct controlled experiments. We have to work with the messy data that we have. When the vast majority of some of the smartest economists in the world who currently live and who have lived, all agree on principle of supply and demand, I find it compelling. When money is removed from circulation, demand drops. This almost always results in a reduction in prices. Rejecting the law of supply and demand is really out there as a fringe argument.