I care less about the use case where I request my own private data.
I care more about the use case where someone else can request any public data I shared, or someone else can export any private data I shared with them only.
For example, I understand that I can be recorded by people's home cameras everywhere I go. I wouldn't support Amazon and Google being legally obligated to turn over that information to anyone who requests it.
I also don't think that any company that hosts public information should be required to turn over its entire database of public information in the digestible format at no cost to anyone who asks
Stop expecting API limits to save you there. We’re beyond that. And honestly it’s better if we stop expecting privacy on public forums.
I understand that every conversation I have outside my home is public, but that doesn't mean I have to support every one of those conversations being recorded and delivered to anyone who requests it
It's quite clear to me from the wording you pasted there that the rules would only mandate that a logged-in user be able to access through the API all data that they could access by logging into the website. You know, exactly what would be necessary to build a third-party app.
In general, I'm struggling to see how that reading of the proposed rules could actually lead to any kind of privacy concerns.
I post about an abortion on my private Facebook profile and a friend uses Facebook 2.0 app, Facebook 2.0 can publish that data for anyone to see on the world wide web, or sell it to advertisers, or anti-abortion groups.
Furthermore, I think we need regulations limiting what social media services themselves can do with data like that as well. And it may be that it would be more ideal if we didn't open up social media services to third-party clients with mandatory APIs until we do have that.
But given the choice between the status quo, and only one of those improvements? I know which one I'd choose.
I agreed meta can use my data. I did not agree that every company can do what they want with it.
This bill has no restrictions on the usage of data exported from the API.