$127 for a heavier rear guard and side guard. What about the change in operating costs from the increased weight and aerodynamic losses?
We could limit all drivers to 30 mph everywhere too. Save lives and gas. Think of the children!
$127 for a heavier rear guard and side guard. What about the change in operating costs from the increased weight and aerodynamic losses?
We could limit all drivers to 30 mph everywhere too. Save lives and gas. Think of the children!
The EPA uses a value of 7.2 million dollars (2006 dollars) for a life saved [1]:
So if adding guards to trucks would save, say, 50% of the lives lost in underride crashes, that would give you a benefit of 200 * 7.2 million * (inflation adjustment). You'd also want to add in the benefits of reduced non-fatal injuries. But for the purposes of argument, let's imagine the benefits of imposing this regulation are roughly 1 billion dollars a year.
All the costs you're talking about are measurable. It's not that hard to then figure out the costs of imposing the regulation and see whether the benefits outweigh the costs.
And this is one of the simpler cases where there aren't complicating factors like privacy or liberty at stake. You're not requiring truck drivers or trucking companies to change their behaviour. All you're asking them to do is fit a couple of extra pieces of steel to their trailers.
[1] https://www.epa.gov/environmental-economics/mortality-risk-v...
If there's a blindness in this article, it's not so much the trucking industry response as it is the question of whether or not this has been implemented anywhere else in the world? https://www.reifflawfirm.com/canadian-and-european-truck-und... suggests that, "in Europe since 1994, front underride guards and side underride guards have been required on large trucks," and that these were strengthened in 2007.
That same page suggests front and side (of truck) collisions with a passenger vehicle are more likely than rear collisions, and that existing US and Canadian protections aren't strong enough.
Safety regulations are written in blood, lots of it.
https://www.imf.org/en/Blogs/Articles/2022/03/28/how-soaring...
There are 13,000,000+ households in the US which face challenges having enough food, at least once during the year.
https://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/food-nutrition-assistance/fo...
When you propose a change that makes food less efficient to ship, you increase the number of people who struggle to feed their families — and make the challenge worse for those who already are struggling.
What the person you’re replying to is saying is that you have to balance the benefits (fewer truck crashes) against the costs (more hungry people) — and that such a choice isn’t nearly as simple as shallow histrionics, about how we must spend money to save lives!
I think your shallow false dichotomy, rather than engaging with the fact that economics also costs lives and causes human suffering, is exactly the problem.
Perhaps the trucking companies' position is a negotiating tactic too. I don't see why they should have to pay the entire cost of a solution that benefits society more than themselves; that's what taxes are for.
[1] https://www.nhtsa.gov/sites/nhtsa.gov/files/2023-04/ANPRM-Si...