Hacker News Reader

Comment by jgw | Hacker News Reader

This has been bugging me for a while, too. Jobs is given (and quite frankly, claimed) credit for far more than he deserves. The sad part about that is that it actually detracts from the many tremendously significant contributions things he did make. But as far as invention goes, I don't think Steve Jobs actually invented anything other than, well, Steve Jobs.

View on HN

Jony Ive mentioned this in the biography, and said it was especially annoying to him since he always remembered who came up with an idea.

It's the same "phenomenon" described by Hertzfeld here: http://folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Reality_Distortion_Fi...

That said, this story is about an invention that Steve Jobs _doesn't_ take credit for. It's another example of how Isaacsons biography gets simple facts wrong by simply quoting people without doing research (just like the NeXT quote by Bill Gates discussed earlier).

Also, I think Steve Jobs comes off as belittling the accomplishments of Woz here, by saying that the power supply was just as revolutionary as the logic board, which apparently is clearly false.

This comes up all the time. Here's a quick way to put that argument to rest, an interactive feature by the New York Times showing the patents Steve Jobs is personally listed on: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2011/08/24/technology/ste...

"CLAIM The ornamental design for packaging, as shown and described."

really?

It's called a design patent. It explicitly covers only the ornamental, non-functional design of the object, and is subject to somewhat different terms than a utility patent.

In terms of IP law, it's actually quite reasonable.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_patent

appreciated, however I don't think that people mean "design" as in aesthetic design when they say "invented"

for example, the spinning beach ball is patented... I think we have passed the point where "patented" has anything to do with what people think of as "invention"

How does this put the argument to rest?

While he did invent lots of stuff, I think it's pretty undisputed by the people close to him such as Jony Ive and Andy Hertzfeld, that Steve was famous for claiming other peoples ideas as his own.

[Edit: Jony Ive describes this in chapter 26 of the biography. See folklore.org for more examples.]

The CEO is on a lot of corporate patent applications for contributing" to the invention. I have seen two CEOs on my applications for patents.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com