I haven't seen much over the years to convince me that he or you are wrong
I haven't seen much over the years to convince me that he or you are wrong
But a few years ago, I found out that his short stories had been collected in a multi-volume series, and I started reading them.
I was pretty crestfallen; I don't use the term "cringey" much, but that's how I would describe a lot of them. I intended to read the whole series, but haven't and probably won't.
Not all of them were terrible, but the famous short stories he wrote were presumably famous because they stood apart.
Also he seems to have flirted with Dianetics in its early days, even basing some of his fiction on it.
So, I guess when you look deeper, he himself proved the law. On an individual basis, you have to produce a lot of crap to generate a masterwork.
I think you can turn this saying around and consider that if 90% of something does not appear to be crap, and you want to understand its true nature, and maybe find some things others have missed, you need to go to the raw data source.
I didn't end up thinking his short stories were as good as I expected, but I did feel like I understood the person better. And even maybe human nature, or how authors progress, a little better.
Definitely agree that it holds true on an individual basis. I've made some music. Most of it's crap. Some of it's alright. Definitely no masterpiece.