"As a software vendor who wants to be benevolent, but not rip myself off, I really like this about Freemium: do “good” and “well” at the same time. ... But for selling software, if you were truly benevolent, wouldn't you give it all away for free? ... I think the solution to the first problem is to price your software (roughly) in proportion to the value customers get from it."
I was trying to say you misrepresented freemium by describing the reasons to use it in terms of social good. A totally ruthless business person may decide to use it because it let's them maximize their profit. Giving away service for less than their cost to the company is all about building or maintaining market share which is why it can be illegal for monopolies to under price their services in the US.
Anyway, their are plenty of models that involve giving away services Drug dealer giving away the first hit, TV / Radio. However, it's only Freemium if you have a built in connection to better service level and keep offering the free service. A Photo sharing site that only let's people download your pictures 100 times an hour before you had to pay would be a freemium service. If using freemium makes you more money than charging people for that level of service how does that fit into social good? I mean you make more money and people who don't pay get a free service what's not to like?
PS: It's easy to use a straw man argument without intending to. Just be careful when you start describing or defining what something really means or what it's benefits are because you can easily overlook what it's about and have a long essay that misses the point.