It can work, and work very well. But electricity is extremely unforgiving of technical incompetence, and financial incompetence can also kill you (generally in the slightly-longer term). If you can't find and keep good managers on both sides (while the big, for-profit players are trying to hire them away, for obvious reason)...then all the feel-goods and eco-friendly bragging rights in the world won't keep your system afloat.
And your system does not need any interference from an actual for-profit utility to suffer organizational failure. Well-intended idiots and short-sighted politicians can do that themselves, in very short order.