But when it is a public utility doing it is "dividends".
But when it is a public utility doing it is "dividends".
If it's ok for a utility to be publicly subsidised (and I think it is) then by the same token it's ok for it to contribute to the public purse. Setting rates as a matter of public policy means rate revenue might end up being more or less than the cost of supply. So what?
Except it's a tax that's functionally invisible because an equivalent public company would've distributed that same profit to shareholders. So the end result is that the local government charges less taxes because some of their funding comes from utility profits.
As a Québécois I prefer it that way, even if a small part of my electricity bill is used as a disguised tax on energy consumption.
When that accumulated surplus gets too large, paying a dividend feels like obviously the right thing to do as well.
If the utility underestimated the cost of providing service, they'll petition the PUC to raise rates, so if they overestimated the cost of providing service, why shouldn't they give it back rather than treating it as a windfall to be distributed to investors?
I'm fine with a public utility getting a reasonable regulated profit, but if they collect more money than they needed to cover expenses, it should go back to the ratepayers. Otherwise the company is just being rewarded for overestimating expenses.
I’m not seeing a categorical difference between these two things, assuming the utility tariffs are subject to approval. The money they receive that is more than their expenses is their profit.
Over time, you tweak the rate increases to get the same outcome as “reasonable profit”
source- attorney involved in private hearings in Sacramento on the PG&E company structure