Doesn't inspire confidence when the average response seems to boil down to a form of religious fervor.
Which is too bad, seems like it would have been the perfect place for a thorough rebuttal.
Doesn't inspire confidence when the average response seems to boil down to a form of religious fervor.
Which is too bad, seems like it would have been the perfect place for a thorough rebuttal.
As for why there isn't much in the way of thorough rebuttals, I suspect anyone trying to formulate one would pretty rapidly run into the wall of reality not agreeing with their existing stance.
Regulated exchanges and coins in cold storage you can’t do much with is the worst of both worlds for those people.
The people who got in later don’t understand “owning” a bitcoin on an exchange and having the key in your possession are VERY different. Those people are idiots.
I assume they all still hold bitcoin or dream of doing so.
One side says "Bitcoin bad!"
I assume they don't hold bitcoin.
I think the idea is sexy, and it definitely harkens back to the earlier hacker/counterculture days of the interwebs.
But I guess I will just sit on the sidelines. I don't even lament selling bitcoin at $300 any more. :)
But now I feel like I dodged a bullet, I could have been one of those zealots that spent all day every day thinking about crypto, and I'm very glad I'm not.
It does sting. But I had to get a car to get to work back then. So there's not much to be mad about.
You make decisions with the information you have. No one had any way of predicting Bitcoin pricing (or the cheap money trend that juiced its price & crypto companies funding rounds).
The original poster makes the key point - the institutions running crypto are unregulated and are doing unverifiable things with customer assets and trades. That rarely ends well. Most of the scams are classic ones. Most of them are in this book from 1841.[1] They've been done before, for other kinds of investments. If you know about John Law's bank, and the Mississippi Bubble, and the South Seas bubble, and tulipomania, and the original Charles Ponzi, you'll recognize all those scams in the crypto industry.
They come back whenever regulation is weak.
- FTX was a bucket shop - a broker not really doing trades, just stealing the customer money.
- NFTs were tulipomania - hype and enthusiasm with no value behind the asset.
- Axie Infinity was a Ponzi scheme - early adopters paid off with deposits of later adopters, until the supply of suckers ran out.
If you know the list of standard financial scams, you can easily slot most crypto schemes into a standard category.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extraordinary_Popular_Delusion...
John points out how any custodial institution gets to operate if they are not trading securities, but any other asset, while using this mere observation to bolster an alarmist view about custodial institutions that trade crypto, as if there is something unique about crypto exchanges, without considering that all spot markets currently can function in the absence of any regulatory framework.
John then amplifies the (unresolved) SEC stance about why the SEC is the most accurate regulatory authority to enact this crusade of getting exchanges into [SEC] compliance or nonexistence. In theory there are also some crypto assets that can be traded on a custodial spot exchange without SEC involvement, such as a Bitcoin-only exchange, alongside…. which other cryptos? Nobody knows but the SEC says its clear!
John hides behind the idea that its the beginning of a broader enforcement gauntlet, while talking exclusively about the SEC enforcement and not any other possibility.
The crux of his alarm is that there is no survivability path, which is also not an absolute. Even in a world where all crypto exchanges must be registered securities exchanges only trading registered crypto securities, the incumbent crypto native operators can participate in that, and establishment investment banking players are already positioning themselves to participate in that world. So custodial crypto exchanges dont go away in any of those scenarios, they just get bigger and more robust for even larger establishment beholden pools of capital.