Engineering: Suddenly Sexy for College Grads
businessweek.com
businessweek.com
There are two types of people who go to college for engineering: those who truly love coding, circuit design, mechanical design, etc, and those who do it for lack of a better thing to do.
The first type are the ones who stay up late hacking, read up on the news, and keep themselves on the bleeding edge. They're the ones who know what they're doing.
The second type invariably just does the coursework needed to pass and get his degree. He's usually incompetent when it comes to his field of study, because his brain is filled with thoughts of paychecks and bonuses, not technical problems.
We don't need them. And I'm sure when the tech industry takes a tumble next time they'll all be gone again, to whatever field promises to be lucrative.
The second type is the type that attempts to turn every class into an orgy of pure memorization, trying to shoehorn every type of problem into a rote formula, while avoiding anything resembling understanding of the material.
The thing that bugs me about these people is not so much that they're incompetent, but they are so because they have no passions. I have a passion for code, other people have a passion for cooking, or writing, or whatever. All of the people I've met in engineering who aren't into it, also aren't into anything else, and I have a lot of trouble imagining how a person can exist in that state. I see so many people who are absolutely driven by the things they love, and somehow these people are just sitting around, not interested in anything except taking home a fat paycheck (to spend on what?)
I wish I had made more of an effort at that time on self-reflection. At least now I know what I want. Live and learn.
I've found they do ok when it comes to questions like "Define and give me an example of a ______", but become utterly lost when given a question such as "Design and implement in pseudocode a set of data structures/classes/etc. to accomplish vaguely-defined task x." As soon as you call upon them to apply their knowledge of theory to something they haven't memorized, they become completely lost. Maybe I'm just worrying over the semantics of the word theory too much.
I agree about how the lack of passion can be unbelievably annoying. Though, it's encouraging you've seen so many driven people, see them as a positive. I wish more people had that same attitude.
And God help them if you describe a bug to them and ask them where they'd begin looking.
In the end it boils down to not doing. To be good at anything you need practice and experience, not just rote knowledge. Type 2s do not have this, since nobody holds a gun up to their head and makes them code till the early morn.
I'd have to agree. I don't think someone solely interested in passing a course is going to help the industry. There's lots of people who go through university solely because they're afraid to enter the real world. I got a job as an electrician because I didn't want to be one of those losers who finally finishes university at 23 years old and realize I have no clue what to do and I wasted a good 5 years of my life.
I agree with the generality, but the more important question is, how do we turn "Types 2s" into "Type 1s"?
They're just misguided, not evil.
It's funny how it seems to be common knowledge in the elite schools that a technical career is to be avoided by people majoring in technical subjects. Perhaps that one piece of knowledge makes the exhorbitant cost of admission worth it. The joke is on the unwashed technical proletariat, after all.