To me (european), I don't like how SpaceX shows off. The technology is cool though, but when I see their kind of communication, to me it sounds like "US marketing".
So yeah... cultural thing maybe.
To me (european), I don't like how SpaceX shows off. The technology is cool though, but when I see their kind of communication, to me it sounds like "US marketing".
So yeah... cultural thing maybe.
We're at an inflection point when it comes to space exploration. Ar this rate, future generations will have days of video and documentation of the accomplishments in America, and a footnote along the lines of "Europe did some things, too. Visit the sub-basement of a library in an office building in Paris for more information."
Also at this rate, future generations will have to focus on surviving with much less fossil fuels (we're passed peak oil), in a world that basically wants to kill them due to global warming.
Chances are that days of video of the accomplishments of the generation that actively destroyed their world (while being fully aware of it) won't be their main concern.
The resulting services and sats actually help in any reasonable climate change strategy.
> Not sure who will spend days watching the same rocket takeoff and land :-).
Here is the thing. Anytime can be the first time for somebody. If you don't make an effort to show everything you do, nobody will ever know you exists.
Yes some space obsessed people will watch everything, and that's fine also. But you never get those people if they don't see something first time.
I am European too and I like how transparent SpaceX is, and they don't even have to be. Arianespace literally tried to hide for 1 year that they had major issues with Ariane 5. When asked why it wasn't launching they were basically saying 'everything is ok'. But eventually journalist got wind off the fact that there were major issues in the fairings.
The culture of secrecy and non-transparency has done nothing but harm to European space flight.
Its not barging to show a video of a test fire or a test launch.
Well it's more than you may think (don't take only the fuel for the flight, but consider the whole construction of the thing).
But more importantly, they are making space a business. The first plane was a drop in a bucket, but it enabled modern aviation. If SpaceX hits their target of 10M per flight... rich people will go have lunch in space.
> The resulting services and sats actually help in any reasonable climate change strategy.
What? I very strongly disagree. But I won't elaborate more than you did.
Currently, no its not.
> don't take only the fuel for the flight, but consider the whole construction of the thing
Making them reusable is a huge gain in efficiency.
> What? I very strongly disagree. But I won't elaborate more than you did.
Earth observation sat measure climate change. We measure the atmosphere with sats. We conduct planetary science. Sat imagery is vital when looking at ecosystems like the Amazon. Space based monitoring is valuable for all kinds of application and can increase efficiency of farming, mining, infrastructure and so on. Weather satellites are vital in many way, including preventing harm people. GPS is a vital technology for so many industries. Space based communication brings modernity to many people who don't live close to major infrastructure.
You simply can't separate modern humanity from space.
Granted space isn't anywhere close to the most important, but it does play an important role. Generally energy production, heating, transport and steel/cement are the real issues. And where the overwhelming focus should be.
> If SpaceX hits their target of 10M per flight... rich people will go have lunch in space.
Just like with aviation we need to consider what regulation we want to apply to these things. I am not against regulating these things.
Your attitude of nobody is allowed to show any pride in anything related to fossil fuels and its general bad and shouldn't be done is simply no way to go forward.
Not saying it should not be done at all. Reusable rockets would be nice, if they were used like the non reusable ones (i.e. rarely). But that's not how technology works: if the technology becomes cheaper, we don't use the same amount for cheaper; we use more.
Can you seriously look at SpaceX and think that they just want to send a few rockets per year, for a fraction of the cost?
> Just like with aviation we need to consider what regulation we want to apply to these things.
That's the thing: if you regulate the rockets market such that it does not start polluting orders of magnitudes more, then it is not a viable market.
> Earth observation sat measure climate change. [...] GPS is a vital technology for so many industries.
We did not need SpaceX for that. Compared to Starlink, Copernicus and all the GNSS satellites (GPS, Galileo, Glonass, ...) just don't count. GPS is something like 30 satellites. Starlink wants to send tens of thousands.
And what if a government doesn't make the necessary investment into fiber? You can stand around here saying what everybody should do all you want, but governments don't just magically do it because you want them to. Those people are just fucked and its their problem?
There are also advantage to using lasers as internet backbone.
In summation, if it wasn't need and it was so easy, why to millions of people want it?
Sure, life without TikTok in every ship and airplane is terrible. /s
> To every mining site? Along every farmers field?
Yeah, to me the biggest problem is really not having fiber while I'm visiting the Titanic. I hope Starlink is working on that. /s
> governments don't just magically do it because you want them to. Those people are just fucked and its their problem?
Is that a new kind of US interventionism? "We believe those people deserve to pay a subscription to our national high-speed satellite ISP. We do it to save them." The world loves US interventionism. /s
> There are also advantage to using lasers as internet backbone.
And disadvantages.
That people like you exists on a platform like Hacker News is actually mind blowing.
Then most of the Internet bandwidth is used for videos, not for corporate e-mails. So... not just TikTok, but I suppose you can make the effort to get my point.
> That people like you exists on a platform like Hacker News is actually mind blowing.
You mean software professionals who don't believe that technology will save us and that we should produce more connected crap because we can?
I like good technology, not profitable technology.
I mean software professional that believe the internet isn't an essential tool for progress.
But then I do believe that most modern technology is bad: we went into this loop of building more crap on top of old crap because it is profitable, completely missing the actual problems we are facing as a species.
We don't need to send (rich) people to Mars, we need to save life on Earth. But engineers don't like this, because most of the fun and profitable projects today go in the wrong direction: they assume infinite growth, and no consequences.
But engineers seem to believe that if they don't work hard to help humanity destroy itself, then it means that they have to advocate going back to horses and no Internet. And in the meantime we are going (faster and faster) towards wars and famine - probably for us, quite certainly for our children.
(Rockets are tiny fraction of fossil fuel usage, <1% of aviation industry.)
Have you met a small child?
I mean, it's cool to have some videos. I watched a few SpaceX launches, and I still will watch the next Starship flights. But it's not like I watch every single launch of every single rocket (does SpaceX even make such an event every time?).