The peak subscriber count I could find was 13 million[1] in 2009. Dropping 3 million customers at $12-15/mo would be scary for any company.
[1] http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/EdwardHunter/20090924/3179/Wo...
[1] http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/EdwardHunter/20090924/3179/Wo...
Surely they know nothing lasts forever, which is why they are working on that other MMO. I have to believe they are smart enough there that this eventual dropoff was too expected to be "scary".
Also, it isn't like WoW is the only thing they have going on. Starcraft 2 was a big hit, and Diablo 3 likely will be too.