They could've defaced your site in high traffic times. They could've logged in and delete your projects on the VPS. Depending on your setup (they had root) they could've searched for your backups. They could've read your mail, if that machine is your infrastructure service - and continue from there (password reset, amazon, buy expensive stuff. password reset, twitter, damage your reputation).
In this case the bits modified were part of a virtual currency and had a more or less clear value. I'd say there could've been worse results of that security hole though and 'don't put anything on a vps' is not a solution.
Bitcoins are no real recognized currency. So you can trade them for USD -> Don't store it?
What about this great project I'm working on? All my stuff on the VPS, because that's convenient and accessible from everywhere. I spent a double digit number of days on it. I have a daily rate for working as a programmer. Don't store it?
You totally ignored (so hard, that I think you didn't read it fully) my post about issues that are harder to value even. Access to your mail can be devastating. Even if you don't store 'money' on that VPS. Putting a dent into your online reputation by messing with your life on the net is hard to value, but certainly damaging. Again, no 'money' stored.
Bottom line: You ignored my point or didn't read my post at all. You picked a line out of context and refuted it with a pointer to the argument _I explicitly tried to prove wrong_.
Also the value something is worth is what someone else will pay for it. You can't value a project you're working on as your hourly rate * hours worked, it doesn't really work like that.
2) 'You can't value a project you're working on as your hourly rate * hours worked, it doesn't really work like that.' Right. But it's totally okay to value ~worthless~ stuff you have according to market rates, although you didn't sell them yet? Why are we talking about ~12k USD here? That's just a couple of bits and bytes on a disk. Yes, he _could've sold_ that at a specific time for a specific amount equaling ~12k USD. He didn't. Why do you assign this value to a highly fluctuating 'currency' on your disk, but don't like me assigning value to a 'yet to be successful' project on disk?
Point 2, back in the day when currency was backed by gold reserves would you have said the coins and notes people had were also worthless? As they are not 'sold' yet into gold?
Also I don't say a project on your disk has no value, a project on your disk has worth, the amount it's worth is how much someone will pay for it. Because the project on your disk doesn't really abide by any fixed standards you will probably find it's quite difficult to sell it.
"In a public cloud environment, additional controls must be implemented to compensate for the inherent risks and lack of visibility into the public cloud architecture. A public cloud environment could, for example, host hostile out-of-scope workloads on the same virtualization infrastructure as a cardholder data environment. More stringent preventive, detective, and corrective controls are required to offset the additional risk that a public cloud, or similar environment, could introduce to an entity’s CDE.
These challenges may make it impossible for some cloud-based services to operate in a PCI DSS compliant manner. Consequently, the burden for providing proof of PCI DSS compliance for a cloud-based service falls heavily on the cloud provider, and such proof should be accepted only based on rigorous evidence of adequate controls."
From: https://www.pcisecuritystandards.org/documents/Virtualizatio...
Amazon:
None of that should be particularly difficult for a VPS provider as large as Linode.
This part isn't doable if you don't own the datacenter. Slicehost has a problem with this because they never owned the datacenters they used.
Simply put, people trust Visa and MasterCard to safely manage transactions, for better or for worse. Regulation like PCI helps ensure that this trust is sound.
The Bitcoin community at large could really benefit from a set of published best practices for managing transactions. Anybody possessing an insecure wallet is ultimately a liability to the credibility of the currency.
*for hackers to get away with the entertaining virtual train robberies we've seen in the last year
Even so, bitcoin seems to attract every shark in a one thousand mile radius.
Afterwards, let's talk about your comparison. Is 'can be stolen' really something that the state can protect you against? Let's discuss it over dinner. Depending on the contents of the wallet I'd pay.
On a more serious note: Your mockery, while amusing, is unrelated to the problem at hand. 'Stealing amounts of $currency from private persons' is not a new idea or something that bitcoin is supposed to change?
1) I don't think PCI is relevant here. If you store bitcoins somewhere and they get stolen then this is, in my world, cash. It's your very own digital cash. Not a credit card. That's why I constructed a (probably poorly implemented) example of someone leaving a wallet full of shiny $currency notes out there.
2) 'What state?' WTH? Can I reply with 'What kind of question is that?' The state I'm coming from is called 'Northrhine-Westfalia' [1]. Now I'm living elsewhere and there are no 'states' here. I can offer the district 'Tel-Aviv'? The point is, 'what state' is invoking aggressive feelings towards your US-centered mindset.
(...) something that the state can protect (...)
and since the PCI (which was what we were talking about) is private, it doesn't make sense to talk about the State.US-centered mindset
The fuck? Firstly, I'm European. Secondly, I assumed you were talking about the State[1], not a particular state.
My take: Someone was mocking Bitcoins with "But all that regulation is evil and it's the freedom of bitcoin that gives it the power" and I tried to make a point saying that _no regulation is involved here_ (laws? certainly). This is a wallet, it got stolen. Your credit cards are protected, your cash is gone for good.
You invoked PCI and I was (and am) unable to make the connection, maybe again because of a misunderstanding? I'm talking cash. Bitcoins are cash in my world (or - at least their value is equivalent to cash, if you choose to sell them).
From there we went downhill and I overreacted. Yes, for me 'state' is exactly what you posted. Again, sorry for the lapse.
I invoked PCI because of the thread: the original post was from klodolph, who said:
(...) You can't process credit cards on a VPS and be PCI compliant (it's against the rules), but any moron can do what they want with bitcoins.
And to that gravitronic replied:
But all that regulation is evil and it's the freedom of bitcoin that gives it the power(...)
"All that regulation" only makes sense if gravitronic is talking about PCI, which was the only regulation cited by klodolph.