That's a terrible security approach. The article makes good points.
That's a terrible security approach. The article makes good points.
His position is more nuanced than that. For a full set of relevant quotes, see https://yarchive.net/comp/linux/security_bugs.html
For instance, this quote seems particularly relevant to this article:
"
[...]
In fact, all the boring normal bugs are _way_ more important, just because
there's a lot more of them. I don't think some spectacular security hole
should be glorified or cared about as being any more "special" than a
random spectacular crash due to bad locking.
[...]
To me, security is important. But it's no less important than everything
*else* that is also important!
Linus
"I think this should go down in history as one of the most meaningless statements ever made.
Thus, is it more or less important that the software functions or that it is free of all security issues?
If there was a condition that your UI became a different shade of grey in your web browser: you wouldnt buy a domain, create a catchy name, generate a logo and scream from the rooftops.
He is just saying: there are important security bugs, there are important functional bugs- they are equally important.
Insignificant security bugs are not more important than deadlocks; which if you were depending on the kernel for a life critical system could kill you.
You could also say it's simply a separate domain to care about security above all else. That is true in all things. If safety was your top priority when designing a saw, you would not design a saw at all and the world would not have the use of saws. So, for the saw designer, the top priorities mostly have to do with how well it cuts. It's someone's job to think about safety as their main whole job, but it's someone else.
I don't see anything so crazy about either of these two concepts.
And sure, no one is forcing the maintainers to adopt a different view, but we can judge them for having a bad or incorrect view, and point out issues that arise from that.
And maintainers are not being asked to focus on security above all else, just to treat security vulnerabilities like vulnerabilities instead of just bugs.
The maintainers view is absolutely incorrect and flawed, ultimately it doesn't matter because distributions pick up their slack.
It's perfectly fine to provide constructive criticism for the bus and advocate for positive change.
Aside from that, we clearly disagree, so I really wish you would stop replying to me since this discussion isn't going to go anywhere.