There is another problem. Instances are already fracturing and forming tight ideological bubbles. See Beehaw. This means that to access all federated content, one will need to have many accounts on many instances. This is really poor UX.
Sure this could lead to echo chambers/filter bubbles, but that is already the case on every platform. I think most people actually want it that way.
This is compounded by the fact that defederation goes both ways. I can’t find an instance which hasn’t blocked at least some other instances. So no matter what, if I want to have access to everything (until such time as I decide to block it), I have to sign up to multiple instances. I also have to regularly check what the owners might have blocked in case I need to sign up for other instances.
I tried really hard to like it, but all in all, Lemmy has been a crappy experience.