Maybe. This is far from clear. It certainly wasn't considered as such by anybody until the 20th century.
My thinking was more so that, regardless of legal enshrinement, “freedom” is a pretty universal component of the American ethos. (as I understand it)
You’d imagine that politicians would love to use people’s emotions on the topic, regardless if they have a de jure reason to oppose a change like gun control, or not, in the case of cars with remote off switches.
But I'll leave that there. I wasn't commenting to put forth a particular political agenda, I was just trying to inject a counterpoint to a thing that I've been hearing more and more that I believe is factually incorrect.
Actual text from the 2nd amendment—pretty obvious why your comment is being flagged.
I consider it a fourth amendment issue. The government has no business remoting into your car, rummaging though its data, and seizing control of your property.
In the US, I am astounded at what is commonly accepted now. Not all that long ago, most people would have thought even the level of surveillance that we accept right now was an impossibly orwellian thing that would never have been accepted.
Yet here we are. I even see people arguing regularly here on HN that these are good things, when just 30 or so years ago, these would have been things that we would have rioted to prevent.
I have come to think that there is no amount of oppression that Americans can't be convinced into.
e.g. https://www.onstar.com/services/stolen-vehicle-assistance
A killswitch that GM puts on your car without telling you because some marketer thought the value-add was a good strategy is not much different than a killswitch that GM puts on your car without telling you because someone else told them to do it.
In both scenarios, a third party can control your car without any real affirmative consent.
If it's now included by default on every car, then yes, I agree with you.
Either way, new cars will factually not have kill switches by 2026 because nothing will be defined until then. How long after is an unknown.
Edit: I made an error with my dates. Lawmakers have until Dec 2024 to make the rules. The earliest a manufacturer can enact the rule is after Dec 2026. But lawmakers can also extend the dates and also have until Dec 2031 to submit barriers and reasons why the system may not work.
https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/3684... SEC. 24220. ADVANCED IMPAIRED DRIVING TECHNOLOGY.
And yes, it's prone to all kinds of abuse by all kinds of "interest groups" …
Obviously I want nobody hurt. But the boomer and silent generation house and senate have, lets just say, tech comprehension problems. I think a 10 minute demonstration to this issue is enough to get them to reconsider that their ideas are utter shit. Especially so if something inconveniences or otherwise annoys them :)
And it never really does.